This article is reprinted with permission from the author, who posted it to her website, inkwithintent.com.
So, you’ve found a ketubah artist, picked out your ketubah text, and had your document personalized to fit your and your Rabbi’s vision. Good work! Time to cross that off your wedding to do list? Not quite. You still need to pick your ketubah witnesses.
Let me tell you a little bit about the various Jewish perspectives on this decision, and then I’ll tell you how we chose our witnesses (spoiler alert – we did things a little differently).
According to Orthodox Jewish law, a wedding ketubah is considered a binding contract as soon as it has been signed by the two witnesses. That means that the signatures of the bride, groom, and Officiant aren’t even required and only began showing up in ketubahs in modern times!
Different Jewish branches have diverging perspectives on who can be a ketubah witness.
Orthodox / Conservative: In Orthodox communities, the two witnesses must be adult, male observant Jews who are unrelated to the bride and groom. Conservative rabbis differ in that the witness does not have to be male.
Reform / Reconstructionist: In more liberal Jewish communities, the rules are often more relaxed and depend on the wishes of the specific rabbi. All rabbis will accept female witnesses, and some will accept wedding guests who are not Jewish as ketubah witnesses. Other rabbis will fall somewhere in between the two perspectives.
Dual Faith / Secular: When you’re having a secular ceremony or an interfaith ceremony with two religions, there is no overarching rule. Talk to your officiant to make sure he or she doesn’t have any specific requirements, but other than that, you can ask whomever you please.
IMPORTANT NOTE: Whatever kind of wedding you’ll have, the most important thing is to talk to your rabbi or officiant ahead of time to make sure you understand any requirements that he or she has. You definitely don’t want any surprises during the ketubah signing ceremony!
It will come as no surprise that signing someone’s wedding ketubah is an enormous honor. After all, you’re asking that person to seal your marriage with their signature, and to support your union in good times and bad.
When my husband and I sat down to talk about who would sign our interfaith ketubah, we agreed that we didn’t just want to ask close friends. After all, there are many ways to honor those you love at your wedding, but signing a ketubah is a special responsibility. So instead, we each spent some time thinking about which friends of ours had the type of marriage that we wanted to emulate in our own relationship. That said, you should choose people who have been a support in your life/lives, and would continue to be so, in good times and bad. Someone you can run to when you need support, which does not mean the person must be married.
I ended up asking my friend Carol. While her husband had passed several years before, I always saw their marriage as a beautiful, egalitarian partnership and as a source of strength and joy for both of them and that was an inspiration to me. My husband asked his friend Mark, whose marriage was constantly filled with adventure, laughter and resilience, no matter what challenges came their way.
Now every time we look at our ketubah, we not only see the words we spend so long crafting together, but also the signatures of two dear friends whose marriages are a constant source of insight.
It may feel as though picking your ketubah witness is an easy task to cross of your list. But I encourage you to really give it some thought, and to pick people who will keep you inspired for many years to come.